|  |
| Customer Reviews: | | Average Customer Review: Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Breezy introduction to issues related to oil and other energy sources May 04, 2010 This book was assigned for an adult education course on the emerging energy crisis. It presents the case that there is a finite amount of oil to be found and produced and that the world is at or near peak production, when half of the available oil has already been extracted. Sometime soon, prices will shoot up sharply, as the world-wide supply contracts. There are chapters on other energy sources: gas, coal, shale oil, heavy oil from tar sands, uranium and hydrogen. All of these potential energy sources have problems.
Defayyes is writing for a non-technical audience. Perhaps for this reason he adopts a breezy style that is entertaining but not always clear. I found myself often wishing that he would stay with a topic a bit longer and more systematically, to explain it clearly. A friend in the class had the same reaction.
The book was written in 2005 and may be getting out of date. For example, since the book was written there have been new developments in producing gas by fracturing shale and then pumping material extensively into the ground. The book's small section on fractured shale could be updated. There are no chapters on producing energy from solar power, wind, or the tides.
Even if you don't buy the main thesis, it's full of info Nov 09, 2009 Ever wondered about coal, or nuclear, or shale, or any of a dozen other alternatives? Or using, say, nuclear and shale in combination? Once you get past the initial thesis of the book, which is that we're past peak oil production, even if you disagree with the idea and are one of the guys who believes oil is not biologically derived, you may be interested in the in-depth assessments of alternative power sources. This is a very informed discussion by a guy who not only knows the facts but has thought about them for a while, something that's usually missing from discussions of power options.
Beyond Oil Sep 23, 2008 Should be required reading especially for anyone who is ignorant or foolish enough to believe "Drill here, drill now" is the solution. The writing is plain English, not geological or oil & gas jargon. Hubbert's peak is carefully explained, and the explanation does not require much understanding of math. The author also explores other energy sources in addition to oil & gas. The basic message is that we need other energy sources now and we had better get cracking.
Timely book Aug 20, 2008 I thought this book sets out the peak oil theory and supporting information in a highly readable way. You can argue about whether it applies to just light sweet crude or to oil in all its forms but the distinction is not that relevant in the short term. I found it both readable and very thought provoking. I have been long oil for awhile as a result and that has been very successful.
Excellent discussion of Hubbert and his technical exposition Jun 27, 2008 Deffeyes has written an excellent book on M K Hubbert's 1969 published predictions for future world oil production.The most interesting chapter is chapter 3.It covers the basic logistics model that Hubbert showed fit the data like a glove fitting your hand.Deffeyes has uncovered a small error in Hubbert's exposition.It is presented on p.51.Deffeyes correctly states that production,discoveries,and hits started together."Hits have to initially grow faster than discoveries.Discoveries have to initially grow faster than production"(p.49) Hits has the highest peak and peaked about 1960.Discoveries then has the next highest peak and peaked about 1980.Production(discoveries and hits)peaked around 2000.
The conclusion is that "the major theoretical conclusion is that a straight line requires that production(discoveries,hits) depends linearly on the fraction of oil that is unproduced(undiscovered,unhit)".(Deffeyes,p.51).The major prediction is that the price of oil will be going up constantly.Possible remedies are conservation,more(much more)fuel efficient cars, nuclear power,solar power,wind power,and cogeneration.The one non solution is to try to drill our way out of the problem.This is not possible given the technical constraints of the problem.
|
|  | |